Quote Originally Posted by atcwag View Post
I am sorry if I have left the impression that this is a common occurance I ride trains all the time and am usually riding the max number of 5 at once. I am overall VERY HAPPY with my experience here at HCW....I have maybe had 5 or less experiences where I thought a "positive with comment on something negative" has been warranted. I am completely ok with potlucks and know that's the way it goes! Other than the one neutral I tried to leave as a TNT before I knew there were other options, I have left nothing but positive feedback and every once in a while I will mention something in a comment that I think needs mentioned. I have contacted a mod once or twice when an envie was completely unacceptable - I think once I got 10 coupons instead of 25 and once I got over 1/2 of the coupons expired. So, I hope I didn't come across as a mean witch in this thread. I simply meant to note that I don't think positive feedback is warranted in certain situations, however I don't think that certain situations require mod intervention either. Specifically, I don't think that mailing an envie 2 or 3 days late (without any explanation or heads up) during a race train would warrant positive feedback without a comment noting the fact, no matter whether the envie followed the guidelines or not. Certain situation such as this were what I was talking about.

You didn't come across as a mean witch at all, just a person who hasn't been happy with train experiences. I guess if you're riding 5 at a time though it really is all relative. No worries.