Quote Originally Posted by empress151 View Post
bought ten post cereals, a mixture of post selects and regular post cereal... only got 1 $5 cat. had to go up to CS, return five boxes, rebuy them and THEN got the other $5 cat after i rebought them. CS had no idea why the second $5 cat didn't print when i bought the cereal in the first place... suggested i do multiple transactions next time.
Check out this post (Shaws: Official Catalina Thread). You will notice that it says "five or more." That's the important part, because it means that you can't double up.

Quote Originally Posted by amandapig View Post
Hmmm...has anyone else been able to double up on this deal? I didn't know you could get two cats at once, but that makes it a better deal if you can! :)
It's not an option with this cat deal. See above.