This may vary from region to region, but it could be worthwhile for you to drop by your Petco. At NYC, the xmas pet toys were all dumped in one bin priced at $.50 each.

There were huge cat stockings (approx. 20" long) full of toys, a variety of dog squeeky or tug toys, large cat advent calendars with small toys tucked in pockets for each day, small cat toys, small cat stockings, and even a lone Hanukkah doggie toy.

Get them now so your cat can be a big deal next xmas when he hands out toys to all his cat pals.