HyVee ~ Catalina: Great Solo Catalina deal 5/16 - 6/8 (money maker!)

[Little Birdie]

I added this to the Catalina thread, but it's a good one and worthy of it's own discussion...

Congratulations! Now, save more! Buy any Solo® cups, plates, or bowls (excludes Solo® cutlery, straws and for season items) between 5/16 & 6/8 Buy (2) & get $1.00... Buy (3) & get $3.00... Buy (4) or more & get $4.00... ..coupon off your next order All items must be purchased in on shopping order. Limited to product in stock. No cash back.

Grab the Solo $2.00/1 Heavy Duty coupon from the 5/18 SS insert and go to town!

Solo Heavy Duty Paper Product, Any - $2.00/1, x08-31-2008, Insert 05-18-08 SS1

I found 9" all occasion plates for $2.38 for 44ct. I bought 3 and used 3 $1/2 coupons for oop of $1.14 (+0.32). I earned a $3 ONYO, for a profit of $1.54. Oh, and I need plates anyway.

[Little Birdie]

Oh, and according to the coupon database, there is a blinkie out there, too:

Solo product, any - $0.55/1, x06-30-2008, Blinkie

[stargazer]

Thanks for the heads up!!! I will be getting these cause I hate to wash dishes in the summer when we grill out so much. Thanks.

[lilcp]

Do these catalinas roll? Can I buy 3 in one order, get a catalina, and buy another 3 using the catalina? TIA

[MamaBird06]

yeah, these will be good for ds's bday party!

[Little Birdie]

Originally Posted by lilcp Do these catalinas roll? Can I buy 3 in one order, get a catalina, and buy another 3 using the catalina? TIA

I don't know. I only had the three $2/1 coupons. If I had had six (or eight) of them I still wouldn't have tried rolling. I do a fair bit of shopping at Hy-Vee; I wouldn't have trouble spending a bunch of ONYOs.

If someone had a huge stack of $2/1 coupons, I could see wanting to roll them to keep the OOP down and avoid collecting a huge stack of ONYOs. If such a person wants to try and then let us know...

[smartmoneymama]

Originally Posted by Little Birdie If someone had a huge stack of $2/1 coupons, I could see wanting to roll them to keep the OOP down and avoid collecting a huge stack of ONYOs. If such a person wants to try and then let us know...

I've got about 15 of these $2/1 coupons. I'm going to try use them, but I don't understand what you're talking about in regards to rolling. Please advise. :)

ETA: Nevermind. I read the OP and figured it out. Off to HyVee to buy plates for the entire summer! I will let you know about the rolling.

[chicana]

I live in Independence and I went to both our Hyvee's. Bought one package just to see if it would work and I didn't get a CAtalina at either store.

[smartmoneymama]

I think you have to buy 2 to get $1 back.

[Little Birdie]

Originally Posted by smartmoneymama I've got about 15 of these $2/1 coupons. I'm going to try use them, but I don't understand what you're talking about in regards to rolling. Please advise. :)

Rolling is like lilcp described.
Transaction 1: Buy the items and earn a Catalina.
Transaction 2: Buy the items, use the first Catalina to pay, and (maybe) earn another Catalina.
Transaction 3: repeat transaction 2 over and over.

Sometimes the machines are programed to prevent rolling; that is, the system detects that you paid with a Catalina from this over and does not issue a new one.

Really the only way to find out if it rolls or not is for someone to try that. I'm not that brave. If it doesn't work, you are out the Cat you could have earned in trans 2.

If someone does try it and reports back that it works, here's the advantage:

Hypothetical Scenario

Jane's store has Heavy Duty Plates for $2.50 and Jane has 15 coupons.

Without rolling...
Transaction #1:
4 packages @ $2.50 = $10.00
4 coupons @ $2.00 = -$8.00
OOP = $2.00 (+tax)
Earn $4 OYNO
-----------------
Transaction #2:
4 packages @ $2.50 = $10.00
4 coupons @ $2.00 = -$8.00
OOP = $2.00 (+tax)
Earn $4 OYNO
-----------------
Transaction #3:
4 packages @ $2.50 = $10.00
4 coupons @ $2.00 = -$8.00
OOP = $2.00 (+tax)
Earn $4 OYNO
-----------------
Transaction #4:
3 packages @ $2.50 = $7.50
3 coupons @ $2.00 = -$6.00
OOP = $1.00 (+tax)
Earn $3 OYNO
-----------------
Total OOP = $7.00 (+tax)
Need to spend 3 $4 and 1 $3 OYNO ($15) before they expire

If rolling works...
Transaction #1:
4 packages @ $2.50 = $10.00
4 coupons @ $2.00 = -$8.00
OOP = $2.00 (+tax)
Earn $4 OYNO
-----------------
Transaction #2:
4 packages @ $2.50 = $10.00
Other groceries = $2.00
4 coupons @ $2.00 = -$8.00
Pay with Catalina = -$4.00
OOP = $0.00 (+tax)
Earn $4 OYNO
-----------------
Transaction #3:
4 packages @ $2.50 = $10.00
Other groceries = $2.00
4 coupons @ $2.00 = -$8.00
Pay with Catalina = -$4.00
OOP = $0.00 (+tax)
Earn $4 OYNO
-----------------
Transaction #4:
3 packages @ $2.50 = $7.50
Other groceries = $2.50
3 coupons @ $2.00 = -$6.00
Pay with Catalina = -$4.00
OOP = $0.00 (+tax)
Earn $3 OYNO
-----------------
Total OOP = $2.00 (+tax)
Other groceries $6.50 worth
Need to spend 1 $3 OYNO before it expires

So, less OOP, and fewer Catalinas to worry about spending.
But I'm too chicken.