Last night I purchased 18 boxes of Pearl scented tampons back to back in increments of 3. Of the 6 transactions, I received $3.00 off each one, and 5 $5.00 off Playtex. So, I think every now and again one does not print, but the vast majority appear to print off. I went thru the regular checkout and did them all with 1 super nice cashier.
Giant/Martin's Foods is also running the regular Tampax on gas rewards this week. For every box of regular tampons I purchased there, I received a CAT for a free box of 18 ct. Sport, or Gentle Glide (up to $4.99). I purchased 4 boxes in 4 separate transactions and received the CAT for each one.
Both are incredible deals. I bet if you purchased 1 at Giant Eagle and gave up the $3.00 CAT, you'd probably get the Playtex one each time (or almost every time anyway).
I had a rain check for the Nature Valley Granola Thins and was able to purchase 12 boxes in 3 transactions at Customer Service yesterday. (I separated them since the cats are still printing)
The cashier at CS was SUPER. She asked if I wanted her to call Corporate to add 60¢ Fuel Perks to my Advantage Card or if I would prefer an $18 GE gift card. I took the gift card! Sweet!!
I just looked at my receipts and the 20¢ bonus Fuel Perks did NOT print for any of my three transactions.
So at least in the Ravenna store, the answer to your question would be "no".