[loaslaen]

Originally Posted by lc71 They were $2.79 each, and I had $.55 coupons that doubled, so $1.69 each which was less than half price. We go through tons of peanut butter, and it is one of the few items that my household is brand loyal too. I think it was $25...the $10 catalina was just a pleasant bonus

Thanks for the info. I think I might have figured out what triggered it. Since you said it had P&G logo, I did a search for catalinas and someone on Hyvee forum said there's one for "Buy $40 of P&G, received $10". Jif regular price would make your total $41.85. So it looks like Bi-lo has this Catalina deal as well. Hyvee's cat. ran in February, did you just recently buy the Jif in March? Wish we knew the dates on this for sure.

As a note, I did read online that P&G originally owned JIF, but sold it to Smuckers. You can find a list of P&G products here although I can't guarantee any/all of them will work. List of Procter & Gamble brands - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia